Goal of Visiting the U.S. Without a Visa Still Eludes Poles

In recent years, the Polish government stood by the U.S., strongly supporting President Bush’s war on terror by sending troops to Iraq and Afghanistan, and agreeing to install parts of an American missile defense system in its territory.

As a demonstration of U.S. gratitude, Poland hoped to be included in the Visa Waiver Program (VWP), which would allow Polish citizens to enter the U.S. as tourists or for business purposes for up to 90 days without having to first obtain a visa. But despite extensive negotiations between representatives of both governments Poland’s dream has not come true, and the chances of Poland joining the program anytime soon are very slim.

Biometric systems to verify travelers identities could help Polands chances of entering the Visa Waiver Program. (Photo: E. Kern-Jedrychowska/Polish Daily News)

Biometric systems to verify travelers' identities could help Poland's chances of entering the Visa Waiver Program. (Photo: E. Kern-Jedrychowska/Polish Daily News)

Currently all but five European Union member countries participate in the VWP. In addition to Poland, which joined the EU in 1999, the other exceptions are Greece, Cyprus, Romania and Bulgaria.

Many Eastern European countries, such as the Czech Republic, Estonia, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania and Slovakia, were accepted into the program in November 2008. Czech Prime Minister Mirek Topolanek said at the time that the decision was “a removal of the last relic of Communism and the Cold War.”

Poland was omitted largely because it failed to meet the required rate of visa refusals. This rate is considered an indicator of how many applicants plan to overstay their tourist visas and possibly work in the U.S. without permission. Currently, in order to participate in the VWP, a country’s visa refusal rate has to be less than 10%.

In 2008, Poland had a 13.8% visa refusal rate, which actually was considered a big success since only a year earlier it was almost twice as high. Moreover, nowadays fewer Poles seem interested in coming to the U.S. Instead, some look for employment within the EU, where many countries have opened their job markets to Polish citizens.

For these reasons, it seemed that the visa refusal rate would soon naturally fall below the required 10% percent and further negotiations between Polish and U.S. officials would not even be necessary.

However, starting July 1, the required rate will be reduced to 3%, making it much harder for Poland to reach the goal.

“This change is a consequence of a bizarre compromise reached by supporters and opponents of the expansion of the VWP in Congress as part of the ‘Implementing Recommendations of the 9/11 Commission Act of 2007,’” explains Pawel Kotowski, a counselor at the Polish Embassy in Washington, DC.

“The required rate can now only be increased back to 10% if the U.S. manages to install biometric air exit systems which will register all the passengers leaving the U.S.by air, a system now only used upon arrival to the U.S. These two things seem to be entirely independent, but that’s how the Congress wrote the law,” Kotowski said.

It is not certain when the air exit system will be installed. Department of Homeland Security spokesperson Anna Hinken says it will be tested at two airports for one month starting in June, and it should be installed around the country sometime next year. Kotowski, however, worries that it may take much longer.

Many members of the Polish American community are upset over the arrangement. After an article on the matter ran recently in Nowy Dziennik/the Polish Daily News, many readers expressed their disappointment at the American policy. Some even called for imposing visas on American citizens who want to enter Poland.

Supporters of Poland in Congress have fought for many years for a more liberal approach.

Some, like Senator Barbara Mikulski (D.-Md.), proposed various pieces of legislation to include Poland in the VWP for its merits and its loyalty to America. But the VWP has many opponents who fear its expansion will make it easier for potential terrorists to enter the U.S.

Without the appropriate legislation it seems unlikely that President Obama will do anything about this issue, even though during the presidential campaign he supported the inclusion of Poland in the VWP.

Department of Homeland Security spokesman Matt Chandler says that efforts are ongoing to gradually solve the issue.

“Countries like Poland, who are seeking inclusion in the Visa Waiver Program, are working with the Department to meet the program’s requirements. This includes lowering non-immigrant visa refusal rates. The Department is also working with Poland to facilitate safe and secure travel through the U.S.,” he said. Chandler would not, however, provide any details about the process.

This is not enough for Polish Americans and supporters of Poland’s inclusion in the program.

“America’s visa policy still treats Poland as a second-class citizen when we tell a grandmother in Gdansk she needs a visa to visit her grandchildren in America,” wrote Senator Mikulski in a statement sent to the Polish Daily News. “The Visa Waiver Program is a critical tool of the ‘smart power’ strategy that President Obama and Secretary of State Clinton have laid out to reinvigorate American foreign policy.”

For Poland, inclusion in the VWP has become primarily a political issue.

“We understand that the legislation sets up the rules. But these rules are archaic and do not reflect our current strategic partnership,” stresses Pawel Kotowski. “We think that the American authorities should consider this little gesture for Poland. It would tremendously improve America’s image among Poles who have always held strong pro-American sentiment. It would also improve the relationship with America’s most trusted ally in Europe.”

9 comments

  1. art78

    Poland is a strong European ally for the US. We dragged them into IRAQ and they deserve our support, at least we can grant them this visa waiver.

  2. Daniel

    Poland should immediately impose entry visa on all USA passport holders entering its borders, including hundreds of thousands of American who visit their families every year. You will see how fast the USA authorities abolish the visa and admit Poland to the VWP.

  3. Shirley Jackson

    Poles, don’t visit America! Learn Spanish. Visit friendly Mexico, Cuba, or South America. Americans hate Poles like you and me so boycott them. If you are in business, learn Russian, German, Hindi, and Chinese and ignore them.

  4. Kasia

    Its a shameful thing that Poland is my home country and I cannot invite my uncle or cousins over for my wedding but their soldiers are expected to support our wars. Revolutionary War, Pulaski, Tadeusz Kosciuszko. George Washington would have died if it were not for a brave pole. But I have come to accept the fact that America and England do not want Poles. They do want Mexicans. Case in point, how after World War I, there was the Polish-Soviet War which is not taught here which was one of the warning signs of World War II. Poles broke the Enigma Code. Poles had more hits in the RAF during WWII. Poles warned England and the USA and other countries of Hitler before he invaded Poland. Yet, America AND England handed us over to the Soviets. The more history I learn the more I am repulsed by the two-faced promises of our politicians. Politicians are nothing more than over paid USED CAR SALESMEN and they can’t prove otherwise.

  5. a US citizen

    I have experienced first hand the arbitrary and I’d even say cruel application of visa policy to Polish citizens. I have seen people with substantial ties with Poland and every intent to return treated disrespectfully by this process. The visa denial rate is precisely in the control of state department employees who have no magic touch in discerning potential immigrants as measured by the cases I know. So, visa denial rates is no measure of illegal immigration; it is a measure of presumption on the part of clerks. I know for a fact in the cases I know that they have been mistaken in denying visas to people who had every intent to return. Polish citizens demonstrate in my experience overall a high level of accomplishment, education and skill deserving of respect and rights rather than this treatment.

    This situation must be addressed and corrected.

  6. commancer

    Not mentioned in the article is another metric used to decide whether Poland can join the Visa Waiver Program and that is the number of Poles who currently overstay or otherwise violate the terms of their visa to the US. Unfortunately a lot of Poles do get US visas and end up working or staying too long – this is making it harder for Poland to earn visa-free travel to the US.

Leave a Reply to Daniel Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *